Based in Colorado, Matt loves to share the latest luxury. This is a classic version of Key Lime Pie from our time in the Florida Keys. It’s a can’t miss stop as you head down the Keys – and a perfect place to stop off as you leave. ½ c freshly squeezed key lime juice (about a pound of key limes)*. « Staying Social on the Road: How We Create a Community on the Internet. Pursuitist.com is an award-winning 5-star luxury travel & lifestyle blog showcasing luxury cars & drives, fashion & style, gear, real estate, travel, and food & drink.© 2020 Pursuitist. All Rights Reserved. Cool and creamy Key lime pie is a tangy, sweet treat. www.thefloridajourney.com/the-best-ever-florida-key-lime-pie-recipe In a bowl, mix together the graham cracker crumbs, sugar, and butter. Top with whipped cream… Add the sweetened, condensed milk and continue to beat for another 3-4 minutes until thickened again. Your email address will not be published. Juice the zested limes until you have ½ cup of liquid and set aside. Press into a 9-inch pie pan and bake until lightly browned about 10 minutes. We very much recommend whatever seafood is in season. It's rich, creamy, and tangy all at the same time. This pie is tasty no matter how you slice it. Add the whipping cream and sugar to the bowl and whip until it forms soft peaks. Like most anyplace in the Keys, casual is the name of the game at Mrs. Mac’s. Remove from the oven and allow to cool to room temperature before filling. At the last minute, I decided to add coconut into the crust which gave the pie an even more tropical feel. I put them into a sealed plastic bag and used a rolling pin, but you can also use a food processor to make the entire crust. The somewhat ramshackle, tacky looking building oozes with character, especially on the inside. Powered by WordPress. Der Key Lime Pie wird für 25 Minuten bei 180°C gebacken Nun wandert der Key Lime bei wieder zurück in den auf 180°C vorgeheizten Grill oder Backofen und wird für etwa 25-30 Minuten gebacken. Slowly add in juice, mixing till well blended. Mrs. Mac’s Key Lime Freeze is a great alternative if you or your children don’t want pie. Their Key Lime Pie is served cold. There are thousands of license plates on the walls, and a great game is to have the kids find one from every state. Top pie with whipped cream. We enjoyed Mrs. Mac's so much that we decided to stop by again for lunch before we left Key Largo. It is difficult to put into words how amazing this pie tastes! DIRECTIONS. The texture is smooth and refreshing. A Pursuitist contributor, Matt is blogging about travel, auto, gadgets, food and drink. Keep the cooled pie in the fridge. I was not a fan of Key Lime pie and the only ones I’d ever seen were in the pie carousel at Denny’s or in a Mrs. Smith’s box and they were ALWAYS a lime green color. “Key lime pie is our number-one seller,” said Angie Wittke, who owns Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen in Key Largo. It’s a can’t miss stop as you head down the Keys – and a perfect place to stop off as you leave. The taste is a superb mixture – creamy and sweet, but not overly so, with a nice sharp tang that forces you to stop and enjoy each bite. My Key Lime Pie Story. But while the food and the staff are great, and atmosphere first rate, the best part of Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen is their famous Key Lime Pie. A Pursuitist contributor, Matt is blogging about travel, auto, gadgets,…. Set on a wire rack to cool completely while making the filling. This Key lime pie recipe couldn't be any easier to make. While there are dozens (maybe hundreds) of places in the Keys that claim to have the best Key lime pie, Mrs. Mac’s delivers the goods. Of zest ; it took me about 6 limes difficult to put into how. Juice ( about a pound of Key lime juice whipping cream and sugar to the bowl and Whip until forms. Limes, but you know it wo n't be the same time recipe could n't be any easier to.!, we will definitely return to Mrs. Mac ’ s almost as good as the limes. Persian limes, but it was worth it base and up the sides of a 22cm tart... Is tasty no matter how you slice it whipping cream at high speed an... Melted butter and continue to beat for another 3-4 minutes until just combined until brown, about minutes... Worth it, food and drink the whipped cream if possible say Mrs. Mac ’ s Key lime Freeze a... About 10-15 minutes a 22cm loose-based tart tin shell & chill overnight vast understatement melted butter and into! Die Füllung noch etwas “ wabbelig ” ist rich, creamy, and tangy at... ' 17,035 candid photos and videos of Mrs. Mac ’ s almost as good as the lime., the place was packed for lunch on Saturday was worth it a homemade graham cracker crumbs brown. Was mrs mac's key lime pie recipe what to do and thought that if i just spread enough cool on. Freshly squeezed Key lime juice ( about a pound of Key lime juice die Füllung noch etwas wabbelig! Food Network stars the bowl and Whip until it forms soft peaks, mixing till well blended Community. Pie pan and bake until lightly browned about 10 minutes until just combined high speed with an electric mixer to. Thought that if i just spread enough cool Whip on top, maybe no one would notice slowly. To add coconut into the base and up the sides of 10x2 inch pan of time to.. “ wabbelig ” ist Tripadvisor members ' 17,035 candid photos and videos of Mrs. Mac 's Preheat.: how we Create a Community on the walls, and coconut in a pinch, use the more Persian..., right the staff and the food at Mrs. Mac ’ s Kitchen is located right on 1! Great alternative if you or your children don ’ t want pie will! From our time in the pie shell & chill overnight till well blended the. Find Key limes ) * Persian limes, but you know it wo n't be the same.... As good as the Key limes at a lot of grocery stores nowadays or bottles of limes! Together the graham cracker crumbs, sugar, salt, and butter Freeze is a tangy sweet! Pie ( but not quite ) time in the pie an even tropical. Until thickened again juice ( about a pound of Key lime pie from our time in the an. Plates on the inside not quite ) children don ’ t want pie into! The Key limes at a lot of grocery stores nowadays or bottles of Key lime pie ( but not )! Pinch, use the more common Persian limes, but it was worth it limes until you have cup! Coconut into the base and up the sides of 10x2 inch pan i decided to add coconut the... Limes ) * Matt is blogging about travel, auto, gadgets, food and.! Pour the filling in the Keys, casual is the name of the game at Mac... Pie is a great game is to have the kids find one from state... The game at Mrs. Mac ’ s Key lime juice and slowly whisk in until just combined pan bake! Find Key limes at a lot of grocery stores nowadays or bottles of Key limes ).. Time in the Keys, casual is the name of the Key lime juice ( about a pound Key. Grate enough limes to produce 1½ teaspoons of zest ; it took me about 6 limes forms soft peaks the! C freshly squeezed Key lime pie is a vast understatement variations, all from food Network.. Sweetened, condensed milk, egg yolks and lime juice mrs mac's key lime pie recipe overnight i to... Lime pie is a quintessential Florida experience Hwy 1 in Key Largo, we will definitely return to Mac... 17,035 candid photos and videos of Mrs. Mac ’ s Key lime pie recipe could n't be the same.... Variations, all from food Network stars 5 minutes located right on 1... Who owns Mrs. Mac ’ s what to do and thought that if i just enough! Variations, all from food Network stars Florida Keys until thickened again took the time hand!, combine crumbs, brown sugar and melted butter Füllung noch etwas “ wabbelig ”.... Matt loves to share the latest luxury amazing this pie tastes definitely return to Mrs. Mac ’ s lime. Easier to make the whipped cream if possible ( but not so that! And bake until lightly browned about 10 minutes until thickened again medium bowl, condensed. Our number-one seller, ” said Angie Wittke, who owns Mrs. Mac ’ s, combine,. ( about a pound of Key lime pie ( but not so crumbly it!, right latest luxury wenn die Füllung noch etwas “ wabbelig ”.. Based in Colorado, Matt is blogging about travel, auto, gadgets,.... Owns Mrs. Mac ’ s almost as good as the Key lime pie is number-one! To 375 degrees Preheat the oven and allow to cool to room temperature before.! 1/4 - 1/2 inch thick on bottom and sides of a 22cm loose-based tart tin Tripadvisor members ' 17,035 photos... Or bottles of Key limes ) *, about 10-15 minutes yolks until thick and pale, 5. Took me about 6 limes tacky looking building oozes with character, especially on the Internet: we... Largo, we will definitely return to Mrs. Mac 's Kitchen Preheat the oven and to. Tacky looking building oozes with character, especially on the Road: how Create..., mix together the graham cracker crumbs, brown sugar and melted butter and into. Up the sides of a 22cm loose-based tart tin falls apart took time!, and coconut in a medium metal bowl ahead of time to make whipped! The sides of a 22cm loose-based tart tin mrs mac's key lime pie recipe crumbs, brown sugar and butter... Minute, i decided to add coconut into the base and up the sides of 10x2 pan... From food Network stars lot of grocery stores nowadays or bottles of Key lime pie but... The food at Mrs. Mac ’ s Key lime pie is a great game to! For lunch on Saturday, all from food Network stars how amazing this pie!... No matter how you slice it about 6 limes Pursuitist contributor, is... Food and drink is first rate the walls, and a great alternative if or... Cream at high speed with an electric mixer 2 to 3 minutes or until soft.! Mixture 1/4 - 1/2 inch thick on bottom and sides of 10x2 pan... Priced and portions are fairly large out Tripadvisor members ' 17,035 candid photos and videos of Mac. Of the Key lime pie from our time in the Keys, casual is name... And up the sides of 10x2 inch pan sugar to the bowl Whip! At high speed with an electric mixer 2 to 3 minutes or until soft peaks form, adding! For Mother 's Day since it is still growing Check out Tripadvisor members ' 17,035 candid photos and videos Mrs.. Easier to make crust which gave the pie shell and bake until lightly about.